Is this a bearing or shock absorber issue
Hi all
I have a Miele W5780 which is only about 6 years old. Yesterday the machine started to make a quite loud clanking sound when spinning.
Can someone please tell me, is this a bearing or shock absorber issue?
I've attached a video to show the issue.
Will add a picture in a subsequent post.
washingmachine.mov
Solution Summary
AI-generated from this discussion
This thread was marked as solved. Here's a summary of the problem and the fix, generated from the discussion below.
Miele W5780 loud clanking on spin with drum running out of true
- The problem
- A Miele W5780, about 6 years old, suddenly developed a loud clanking/thumping noise on spin over the last couple of washes. The original concern was whether it was bearings or shock absorbers. The machine reportedly behaved the same even with nothing in the drum.
- Likely cause
- The strongest diagnosis in the discussion was that the inner drum was running badly out of true rather than a simple bearing fault. A forum reply noted the changing gap between the drum and outer tub as it rotated, suggesting a distorted or damaged drum assembly, with a possible drum spider problem mentioned as a probable explanation. Bearings were considered less likely because the symptoms described did not match the usual rough, rumbling bearing failure.
- What fixed it
- Recommended checks were to inspect the pump filter and sump hose for any foreign object that might have damaged or knocked the drum out of true. The advice was that if it shook like this with an empty drum, the drum assembly would probably need replacement, and to ask Miele for a repair quote. The exact repair was not confirmed.
- Checks to try
- Observed that the machine made the same noise with an empty drum
- Visual check of the drum while rotating showed the gap to the outer tub changing drastically
- Suggested check of the pump filter
- Suggested check of the sump hose for a foreign object
- Parts or tools mentioned
- Inner drum
- Bearings
- Drum spider
- Pump filter
- Sump hose
Safety: Further diagnosis should be carried out by a suitably qualified appliance engineer.
17 Answers
Hi. Was there something in the drum on that video? It looks like there was just 1 or 2 items in? If so that would cause it do be out of balance and thump about unevenly. What's it like with nothing in?
Need Professional Help or Spare Parts?
Here is a pic of the drum front on.
Hi Andy
It is the same without anything in it, I just don't have a video of it.
Here is a link to a video with my just spinning it with my hand. https://photos.app.goo.gl/kTSAVAcu59M7Nuns8
That drum looks quite elliptical. That would explain why the drum is so unbalanced when spinning. It looks bad. Has it suddenly happened or has it been noisy for a while?
Need Professional Help or Spare Parts?
Only happened in the last couple of washes. Would you suspect its the bearings?
Drum bearings usually have a deep rumble and when you spin the drum by hand it feels nobbled and rough. They don’t normally cause the drum to run so out of skew.
They also don’t fail so quickly and normally slowly become noisier and noisier. The Miele front drum bearing is also very large. About twice the size of ordinary ones.
It looks like the drum spider could have a problem but again the Miele drum spider is really well made. It’s almost as if the drum has been knocked out of true. Has anything got inside it to cause it to become out of shape or any sign of any physical damage to it?
Need Professional Help or Spare Parts?
No there doesn't seem to be anything inside, and the drum is still in perfect shape.
How would one even begin to understand what the issue is?
Is it worth me getting Miele out to look at it?
If you look at the gap between the top of the drum and the outer tub at the top as the drum spins (on the video) the gap changes drastically by about 2 inches. The drum looks completely out of true.
Need Professional Help or Spare Parts?
Yes it does, its quite worrying for us as we really need to use the washing machine.
What do you suggest as the next steps?
If it is shaking about like in the video with nothing in the drum then the drum is completely out of true and would probably need replacing. Have you checked inside the sump hose and pump filter in case any object that could have knocked it out of true can be found?
Need Professional Help or Spare Parts?
No I haven't done that, I'll have to work out how to do that this weekend. I don't believe Miele would replace the drum if that was an issue as its too costly for them.
How long is the guarantee? Some of their washers have 10 year guarantees.
Need Professional Help or Spare Parts?
It was only 5 years so we are just out unfortunately.
It’s a tough decision because 6 years is no age for a Miele. It ought to last at least twice as long as that. A repair is likely to be very expensive but still hundreds less than a new one.
I’d ask Miele for a quote for what it would cost if it needed a new inner drum and bearings.
Need Professional Help or Spare Parts?
They said they would charge £130 for a call out, if its the bearings they wont repair it, but they will offer 50% off a new machine.
Wow. That’s crazy that Miele won’t repair their own machines that are built to last 20 years but only 6!
But that sounds like a decent offer.
Need Professional Help or Spare Parts?
The question is, do I really trust Miele now. I'm going to do some homework and see what else is decent out there.
Your Answer
Sign in to share your expertise and post an answer.
Related Questions
Washing machine grinding sound before drum spins- is it definitely the bearings??
1 answer • 2 replies
EWD81483WUKN 869991618990 Drum Bearing Failure
1 answer • 1 reply
Bosch serie 8 bearings
1 answer • 1 reply
Bearings?
1 answer • 7 replies
New World WDHT714W Bearing problem / Belt
1 answer • 5 replies
Hotpoint Aristo Model WMG 823B EU.C. bearing replace
1 answer • 1 reply
Bearings failed after just 15 months
1 answer • 6 replies
Ball bearing replacement top loader
1 answer • 16 replies
Welded sealed tub/drum bearing replacement - options for fixing it back together
1 answer • 2 replies
Hoover HWB 814 DN1 new bearings
1 answer • 3 replies
